UdeyJohnson.com

The Revolt of the Masses

8/14/2011

3 Comments

 
PictureLe Pont des Artistes' grilled wall 10 years ago
Ahhh - Paris. The most beautiful city on Earth - and the number one tourist destination too. More people visit Paris each year than any other travel destination. How many? Statistics vary (for some unknown reason) from 35 all the way up to 58 million annual visitors. But whatever the actual figure is - it's a lot. I mean, consider that the leading attraction there - Notre Dame Cathedral - in 2008 saw 13 million visitors. That's over a million a month. And every year sees more. Many more.

I love Paris. I could write 15 pages on just the things that are great about the 'city of light'. But every time I visit, the increase in the number of tourists is clearly noticeable. The first time I visited the Musée d'Orsay (mid 90's) there was no line to get in and plenty of elbow room once inside. But on a visit this spring, I waited in a very long line for over an hour, and once inside it seemed more like a packed metro station than a museum. And this is true of all the major venues. There are mobs of tourists all over Paris now.

PictureAnd today - the art of the masses
You Call That Love?
As bothersome as this is, an even more troubling development, which I first noticed 3 years ago, has now developed into a full-blown plague. It's graffiti. And not just your average spray-can variety left by local teens - but tourist-generated graffiti. And the irony is that the tourist graffiti is ostensibly a sign of each tourist's love of the beauty of Paris.

It first started less than 5 years ago. I was walking across the Pont des Artistes - a pedestrian-only bridge on the Seine - when I noticed 3 or 4 padlocks in the bridge's grilled wall. And on each padlock was written the names of two lovers. After inquiring, I was told they'd been locked there as a sign of the lovers' unbreakable bond to each other - and to Paris. "Interesting", I thought. Even a tad romantic. And I forgot all about it.

Then - as I walked across the same bridge a few months ago - I was stunned to see not just 3 or 4 such signs of "love" - but literally hundreds. Padlocks of every imaginable variety and color, each with names written on them - and each permanently sealed in-place. And what had once been a simple, and delightfully artistic grilled-wall, was now a cluttered monstrosity resembling more a junk-yard than anything else. 

PictureThe cancer spreads
Et Tu Bruté?
And like any plague - it is now spreading. Each and every bridge in central Paris with such a wall is now being targeted by these "lovers" of the city. And the cumulative impact of this love-fest is the slow, methodical destruction of one of the great works of art in Paris; the sublime simplicity of her bridges. 

In his book The Revolt of the Masses, Jose Ortega y Gasset asserted that the advent of the consciousness of 'mass man' as a social phenomena is new to the age of industrialism. And further, that this 'mass man' intervenes in everything - and that this intervention is solely by violence. 

When I first read that in college, I didn't understand what he meant. But now, each time I walk across the Pont des Artistes (once upon a time, my favorite), I not only understand, but I also mumble a quiet, "Amen". 
Sadly.

3 Comments
Stacey Washington link
8/15/2011 04:20:22 am

I've not yet made it to Paris (someday) but your blog reminds me of how I feel when I return to my hometown Detroit though I'm sure the Detroit blight wasn't created out of "love" for the city. I look forward to your next post!

Reply
Patty Mooney link
8/15/2011 05:24:03 am

Ewwwww. I know the feeling of dismay and disgust. I wrote about it in a blog post about graffiti in natural settings. http://sandiegovideoproduction.blogspot.com/2011/05/drop-spray-can-chachi-by-patty-mooney.html People want to be different, and recognized, and make a literal "mark" on their world. The more people, the more of said marks.

Reply
Joseph Cyr link
8/27/2011 03:55:16 am

hey there...saw the link to your blog from the afar.com website...I lived in Paris years ago; haven't been back recently, but am a bit dismayed to see, from your photos, that the padlock-thing is beginning to mar Paris! I spent a good chunk of this summer in Seoul and that was the first time I'd seen so many of the 'love-padlocks'--they were on a mountaintop vista point, and seemed kind of quaint...but to see them in Paris along the Seine? Let's hope it's a fad that passes--might sound unromantic, but the love-padlocks do become an eyesore. Maybe Paris could cut off the padlocks and make some sort of public art out of them? That's what the Seoul gov't is doing with some of the locks there...Bonne Continuation avec votre blog!

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Picture

    Author

      I'm a writer living in the San Francisco Bay Area and Montréal, Québec - and this is my blog.
     Some of my writing is practical, some philosophical, but all of it generally accurate and occasionally amusing. 
     You might stumble on a rant here and there - but otherwise it's a pretty relaxed, fairly interesting spot to spend a few minutes.
    Welcome.

    Follow UdeyJohnson on Twitter
    My latest eBooks 
    also available at Smashwords
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Receive a FREE copy of Paris - Without the Tourists
    when you subscribe to my mailing list.

    RSS Feed

    Categories

    All
    Art
    Culture
    Diego Rivera
    Food
    History
    Iphone
    Montréal & Québec
    Montréal & Québec
    Paris & France
    Peru
    Philosophy
    San Francisco & Calif.

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.